Sunday, July 25, 2010

Hmmmmm.

I found this opinion on a feminist mormon housewife blog and found it thought provoking.
Traditional Marriage is Dead (and it’s a good thing too)
By: Not Ophelia - June 26, 2008

The bloggernacle is awash with posts on same-sex marriage, the First Presidency’s upcoming letter and the demise of traditional marriage. Over and over I read comments about how ‘traditional marriage’ is under attack. How gays and lesbians marrying will ‘destroy marriage.’ How we have to fight to defend ‘traditional marriage’ and the family from variously, the homosexual agenda, the evils of the world, the forces of Satan, etc. etc. etc. But the sad (glad) news is that Traditional marriage is dying or dead in much of the world and has been for a long time. And its demise has nothing to do with gays or lesbians. It was us women who killed it, forced its reinvention and started us down this ’slippery slope’ to where we are today.

What we call marriage in this country is a very recent invention. Throughout the millennia marriage has been, not about two people who love each other and want to share a life together, but rather about power, property and paternity. About male control of women’s work, women’s lives and women’s fertility. The importance of virginity, the stigma of bastardy, the ‘head of the household’ status, coverture, and in some cultures arranged marriages, bride price, dowries, honor killings, and the right of husbands but not wives to divorce at will — all of this was (or shamefully still is) part of the effects of traditional marriage.

These basic underpinnings of traditional marriage cross cultural boundaries. Yes, the monogamous found the polygamous found the polyandrous to be barbaric and uncivilized and just plain wrong. Not too much tolerance there. Nevertheless, things like monogamy vs. polygamy were differences of degree, not type. Traditional marriage began it’s decline the day women became autonomous people. The day our status became human, not property.

So we (our culture and our religion) had to redefine marriage to be relevant to 21st century life. We now talk about love and sharing our lives and being equal partners and mutual respect. Because of this, the world and the church have had to reinvent marriage. Society has reinvented it through laws. Many decry no-fault divorce, but once marriage became a joining of two loving, devoted and equal partners, it’s hard to force one to stay when he or she no longer wants to. Others decry same-sex marriage, but once society redefined marriage from a chattel arrangement to one between equals you need more reasons than unshared religious values or the ‘ick’ factor to prevent them from marrying the one they love.

The church has also reinvented marriage, most recently in the Proclamation on the Family. But as grand or inspired as you might find that document, it doesn’t reflect the reality of what marriage in the church was 100 or 50 or even 20 year ago. Re-read the polygamy parts of D&C 132, or ask someone who took her marriage vows before 1990 what she covenanted: it was a kind of marriage quite foreign to the one described in the Proclamation on the Family.

The LDS church has already reinvented marriage to conform to our ideas of morality and modern culture. Others have too. The battle now isn’t over whether ‘traditional marriage’ will survive but rather over who gets to have their redefinition accepted by the rest society.

2 comments:

Julie said...

I have another comment. Marriage between a righteous man and woman who obey the commandments and treat eachother with respect and devotion and work together to raise children is the best thing that society could have. Happiness and fulfillment would abound. Yes, there would still be free agency and people would make mistakes, but there would be so much less striff and immorality. It has worked beautifully for us in our marriage. We work as equal partners and I wouldn't have it any other way. I am so engaged in trying to do what's right in my marriage, neighborhood and at church I don't have time to question. I really have it all, I know. Why am I so blessed, when there are millions or billions of women who live in opression in their relationships???!!!! Oh, I feel such compassion for them...I want them to have the gospel and a wonderful husband who would do anything for them!

Tiffany said...

Sandy-I love that you really think about things! Too many don't.